money, home, coin-2724235.jpg

FD vs NPS vs NSC vs PPF vs ELSS: comparison and which one is better?

Here we look at 5 different investment schemes one can use for investment and tax saving purpose

FD:
  • A fixed deposit plan is a risk-free investment tool that offers investors guaranteed returns. 
  • The money you park in an FD is locked in for a given period varying from 5 years to 10 years.
  • FD rates are fixed when you open the account and remain constant throughout the investment period, ensuring stable returns. 
  • However, the interest rates applicable on an FD account will vary as per the tenor of investment. 
  • The principal amount plus the compounded interest on the sum is payable only at the end of this investment tenor.
NPS:
  • The NPS (National Pension Scheme) which is a government-sponsored pension programme started in 2004. 
  • While initially only open to central government employees, the scheme’s eligibility window was expanded in 2009 to include employees from the public, private and unorganized sectors. 
  • The National Pension Scheme is not open to those employed in the Armed Forces.
  • Under NPS, you have to invest small proportions of your salary every month to ensure a steady pension during your retirement years. 
  • Pension from NPS scheme details investments that are guaranteed since the programme is administered and regulated by the Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority (PFRDA).
NSC:
  • One can buy government regulated certificates from post offices
  • This is a five-year fixed income savings bond investment scheme. 
  • One can invest a minimum of Rs 1000 and further in the multiples of Rs 100. There is no upper limit. 
  • A single holder type certificate can be purchased by an adult for himself or on behalf of a minor or by a minor.
  • Deposits qualify for tax rebate under Sec. 80C of IT Act. The interest accruing annually but deemed to be reinvested under Section 80C of IT Act.
PPF:
  • PPF is a long-term investment option and one can deposit a maximum of Rs 1.5 lakh per year under this scheme. 
  • However, note that the money invested in PPF remains locked in for 15 years.
  • After the PPF account’s maturity period of 15 years, it can also be extended by a 5-year block. 
  • It also comes with the options of early withdrawal, but that too after a certain period of time. 
  • For instance, partial withdrawals can be made after 7 years. 
  • An advantage is PPF investments and withdrawals are both exempted from tax. 
  • Additionally, the corpus received at the time of its maturity as well as the interest earned is exempted from tax.
ELSS:
  • Equity-linked savings scheme is an open-ended Equity Mutual Fund
  • One of the most productive tax-saving options wherein you can start investing from as low as Rs 500. 
  • ELSS comes with a mandatory lock-in period of 3 years from the date of investment. 
  • With the ELSS scheme, investors can invest around 65 per cent of their funds in the equity market. 
  • The rate of interest received on investment in ELSS is directly linked to the market performance. 
  • Additionally, investments in this scheme also qualify for tax deduction under section 80C and fall under the EEE category. 
  • Investors planning to invest for longer periods ranging from 5 to 7 years should opt for this equity scheme.
Comparison of different Investment schemes
Features Tax saving FD NPS NSC PPF ELSS
Eligibility / Who can invest? - Resident Individuals (18+)
- Non Resident Individuals
- HUF
- Minor can also invest jointly with an adult
- Resident Individuals (18 - 70 yr)
- Non Resident Individuals (18-70 yr)
- Resident Individuals (10+).
- Jointly (up to 3 adults),
- guardians on behalf of a minor.
- Resident Individuals (18+) [one account per individual]. - Resident Individuals (18+)
- Non Resident Individuals
- HUF
Tax on returns or interest - Taxable on Interest Earned (as TDS) - 25% is exempt from tax on premature withdrawal.
- 40% is exempt from tax on maturity withdrawal.
- Taxable on Interest Earned (as TDS) - No Tax on Interest Earned - Taxable on Interest Earned (as Capital Gain)
Tax Benefit / Tax Deduction on Contribution Eligible for 80C deduction Eligible for Sec 80CCD (1) and 80CCD (1B) deduction
** There is no tax benefit on investment towards Tier II NPS Account.
Eligible for 80C deduction Eligible for 80C deduction Eligible for 80C deduction
Minimum Investment Amount 1000 Rs No minimum limit 1000 Rs 500 Rs 500 Rs
Maximum Investment Amount No upper limit, No upper limit No upper limit 1.5 lakh No upper limit,
Maximum Tax Deduction 1.5 lakh 2 lakh 1.5 lakh 1.5 lakh 1.5 lakh
Interest Rates / Returns 6 - 7 % 9 - 12 % 6 - 8 % 7 - 8 % Upto 20%
** Market dependent
Tenor/Investment period/What is the maturity period? lock-in period of 5 years Till age of 60 years lock-in period of 5 years 15 year lock-in period of 3 years
Premature Withdrawal / Partial Withdrawal No Yes
Govt Sector:
- Complete (100%) Lump sum withdrawal allowed if the corpus is equal to or below ₹ 2.5 Lakh.
- Complete (100%) Lump sum withdrawal allowed if the corpus is equal to or below ₹ 2.5 Lakh.
- If the corpus is higher than ₹ 2.5 Lakh, then 20% can be withdrawn.
Non Govt Sector:
- 10 Years mandatory subscription
- Complete (100%) Lump sum withdrawal allowed if the corpus is equal to or below ₹ 2.5 Lakh.
- If the corpus is higher than ₹ 2.5 Lakh, then 20% can be withdrawn.
No Yes
Premature closure of the PPF account is allowed only 5 financial years after the account is opened. 1% penalty is levied from the actual rate of interest that was given by the account
No
Loans against investment No No Yes Yes (up to 25% between 3rd to 6th year) Yes
Matured Sum 100% of the matured sum - Complete (100%) matured sum, if the corpus is less than or equal to ₹ 5 Lakh.
- If the corpus is more than ₹ 5 Lakh, 60% can be withdrawn.
- In case of death after 60 years, a lump sum is paid to the nominees.
100% of the matured sum 100% of the matured sum 100% of the matured sum
What is the investment limit? No Limit No Limit No Limit 1.5 lakh per year No Limit
Are NRIs eligible for this scheme? Yes Yes No No Yes
Risk / Risks Involved Low Risk
** only risk is FD provider
Risky
** Returns depend on the investment and market
Very Low Risk Very Low Risk Risky
** Returns depend on the investment and market
Safety Provided by Banks and financial institutes hence depends on the stability of the entity. Come under Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority which is under the jurisdiction of Ministry of Finance of the Government of India Come under India Post, under the jurisdiction of Ministry Of communication of the Government of India The scheme is fully guaranteed by the Government of India Provided by financial institutes hence depends on the stability of the entity.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Shopping Cart
  • Your cart is empty.